r/truenas
The best-value NAS drive right now isn't a NAS drive - here's what's actually cheaper
- upvotes
- 20
- comments
- 2
Post
Are you buying drives for a pool soon? Here's what the current US prices and Backblaze data say, because the regular forum wisdom is a bit out of date. CMR vs SMR is still the first filter. An SMR drive looks fine until a resilver, then the long writes choke it and it can time out and drop from the vdev - exactly what the whole 2020 WD Red mess was about. It is worth checking the specs before buying anything. On capacity, the best price/TB right now sits around 18TB-22TB. Under 16TB you pay the tax on small-drives (fixed costs per drive for components), and the new 30TB drives are still priced too high (around $47/TB). The value lies around 20TB. For example: 18TB Exos recently dropped to $600 ($33/TB), 20TB WD Gold is $36/TB, 22TB Ultrastar $38/TB. The surprising part is: at every capacity, the cheapest drive per TB is an enterprise one, not a NAS drive. Exos, Ultrastar, Gold and Toshiba MG all undercut IronWolf and Red per TB right now. The usual "enterprise costs more" assumption is just backwards at the moment, and for a pool it's a good deal. It means higher workload rating and a 5-year warranty for the same money or even less. On reliability: most current drives are a tie. Almost everything current is <1% annualized failure rate in Backblaze data, and the best (a 24TB Toshiba MG11 and a 14TB Ultrastar) sit around 0.5%. In reality, 0.8% against a 1.0% is the same...
Keep reading with a free account
The rest of this post, and every signal for Seagate, is in your free account.
Extracted from these lines
The one exception worth flagging is the 24TB Exos ST24000NM002H at 3.24% on a ~9,600-drive sample - about 6x the best, so probably one to avoid for a vdev.
From the post
Failure rates are from Backblaze lifetime Drive Stats (Q2 2026 report), and CMR/SMR is from manufacturer datasheets.
From the post